AutoTrader vs CarGurus: Where to Buy and Sell Your Next Car?

Difference between AutoTrader and CarGurus AutoTrader vs CarGurus

AutoTrader is an online car marketplace with an extensive inventory and various seller options, while CarGurus uses a proprietary algorithm to provide a “deal rating” system for price analysis and offers a more streamlined user interface.

This article will comprehensively compare the difference between AutoTrader vs CarGurus to help you determine the right choice.

Watch Video >> The Difference between AutoTrader and CarGurus (AutoTrader vs CarGurus)

Introduction: AutoTrader vs CarGurus

When buying or selling a car, the traditional method of visiting a dealership or browsing classified ads has largely been replaced by the ease and convenience of online platforms.

These digital car marketplaces have transformed how we purchase and sell vehicles, offering a huge inventory of cars from across the country and a plethora of information about each.

Two names often rise to the top among these platforms: AutoTrader and CarGurus. However, these two services are not created equal and have distinct differences that cater to different needs.

What is AutoTrader

AutoTrader is one of the oldest and most trusted online car marketplaces. It’s been in the business since 1997 and has become a go-to resource for millions of car buyers and sellers. AutoTrader is renowned for its massive inventory, including new and used cars from dealers and private sellers.

One of the distinct advantages of AutoTrader is the sheer breadth of its search options. Users can filter vehicles by various parameters, including make, model, year, price range, mileage, location, fuel type, and more.

There’s even an option to search for cars with only one previous owner. The platform also offers an extensive collection of classic and exotic cars for car enthusiasts.

AutoTrader also offers various tools and resources, such as car reviews, comparison tools, and loan calculators. The website also provides articles on car buying and selling tips, maintenance advice, and the latest news in the auto industry.

What is CarGurus?

CarGurus is a newer player in the online car marketplace industry but has rapidly gained popularity due to its unique features. Launched in 2007, CarGurus utilizes a proprietary algorithm that analyzes and compares prices and features of millions of current and historical car listings.

CarGurus’ standout feature is its “deal rating” system, which analyzes each car’s price, mileage, condition, history, and other factors compared to similar listings on the site. The algorithm then assigns a rating from “overpriced” to “great deal,” which helps buyers quickly assess the value of a listing.

The platform also offers a large inventory of cars from dealerships and private sellers. Additionally, CarGurus provides various resources like expert reviews, financing tools, and user forums where car shoppers can ask questions and share their experiences.

Difference between AutoTrader and CarGurus

User Experience

Both AutoTrader and CarGurus have intuitive and user-friendly interfaces. Both offer advanced search filters to help you find the perfect vehicle according to your needs.

However, CarGurus may have a slight edge in this category because of its clean, uncluttered layout and deal rating system that helps users quickly identify good deals.


Both platforms boast many vehicles, including new and used cars from dealers and private sellers. The inventory fluctuates daily, but you can expect hundreds of thousands of listings on both platforms.

Price Analysis

This is where CarGurus shines. Its proprietary deal rating algorithm analyses each car’s price relative to similar listings. This tool can be invaluable for buyers who want to get a good deal.

AutoTrader, on the other hand, doesn’t provide an in-built price analysis feature. However, they do offer a free car valuation tool which can be used to understand the market value of a particular car model.

Seller Options

Both AutoTrader and CarGurus allow for listings from private sellers and dealerships. However, AutoTrader offers a few more options for sellers. For instance, they offer various listing packages that allow for different numbers of photos, lengths of listing durations, and ad placements.

Additional Resources

Both platforms offer a wealth of resources beyond their car listings. AutoTrader provides car reviews, buying and selling guides, finance calculators, and industry news. CarGurus also offers expert reviews, financing tools, and a user forum.

AutoTrader vs CarGurus: What’s the Difference?

Year Established19972007
User InterfaceAdvanced search filters with a broad range of parametersStreamlined, clean interface with a unique deal rating system
InventoryNew & Used Cars from Private Sellers & Dealerships, with an extensive collection of Classic & Exotic CarsA comprehensive selection of New & Used Cars from Dealerships and Private Sellers
Price AnalysisProvides a free Car Valuation Tool but no direct price analysis on listingsThe Proprietary Deal Rating Algorithm analyzes and rates the value of each listing
Seller OptionsOffers various listing packages with different features (number of photos, listing durations, ad placements)Standard Listing Options
Additional ResourcesCar Reviews, Buying & Selling Guides, Finance Calculators, Industry NewsExpert Reviews, Financing Tools, User Forum
Difference between AutoTrader and CarGurus (AutoTrader vs CarGurus)

Can I negotiate prices on both AutoTrader and CarGurus?

You can negotiate prices on both AutoTrader and CarGurus. Both platforms are online marketplaces that connect buyers with sellers, facilitating direct communication between the two parties. As such, the listed prices are not typically final; they serve as a starting point for negotiations.

On AutoTrader, you can contact the seller directly through the platform to discuss the price. CarGurus, on the other hand, provides a suggested price range for the vehicle and its proprietary deal rating system, which can be used as a benchmark in price negotiations.

Remember, the ability to negotiate effectively will depend on factors such as the demand for the car, the urgency of the seller, and your negotiation skills. As always, it is important to do your research to ensure you are getting a fair deal.

Can you find the same cars listed on both AutoTrader and CarGurus?

The overlap can occur because both platforms are open to dealerships and private sellers who can list their vehicles on multiple online marketplaces to increase visibility and potential sales. Consequently, the same vehicle can be found on AutoTrader, CarGurus, and possibly other car-selling platforms.

However, even though the inventory might overlap, the user experience, search functionality, additional features, and services can vary significantly between the two platforms. For example, CarGurus offers a deal rating system to provide quick insight into whether a car is priced appropriately.

On the other hand, AutoTrader provides a wide range of search filters, including the option to search for cars with only one previous owner.

Regardless, when shopping for cars online, checking multiple platforms is recommended. Each site might have unique listings, and the same car might be priced differently across platforms, allowing you to negotiate or find the best deal.

Do both AutoTrader and CarGurus provide car history reports?

Both AutoTrader and CarGurus offer access to vehicle history reports to assist buyers in making informed decisions.

These reports are crucial as they provide important information about a vehicle’s past, including previous ownership, service history, accident history, title status, mileage verification, and more.

On AutoTrader, vehicle history reports are usually provided through third-party services like AutoCheck or CARFAX. Not all listings on AutoTrader will have a history report available; it often depends on the seller’s choice to include this. If a report isn’t readily available, it’s advisable for buyers to request one or acquire one independently.

CarGurus, on the other hand, provides a vehicle history report for every car listed by a dealer. AutoCheck, a part of Experian, provides the reports.

The vehicle history report is conveniently linked on the vehicle details page. Private sellers may not always provide these reports, so buyers may need to obtain one separately.

Although vehicle history reports are vital when buying a used car, they should be just one part of your research. Always consider having the vehicle inspected by a trusted mechanic before purchasing.

Conclusion: AutoTrader vs CarGurus

Ultimately, the choice between AutoTrader and CarGurus will depend on your needs and preferences. AutoTrader might be the best fit for you if you prioritize a large inventory with a wide range of search filters and prefer to get your information from articles and guides.

On the other hand, if you value a streamlined user experience and a built-in price analysis tool to identify good deals quickly, CarGurus might be your best bet.

Of course, there’s no rule that says you can’t use both. By comparing listings across both platforms, you can ensure you’re seeing a broad range of vehicles and potentially finding the best deals.

Regardless of which platform you choose, the important thing is to do your research and make an informed decision. Happy car hunting!

Read more articles

Cinch vs Cazoo: Which is the Best Online Car Buying Site?Difference between PCP and HP Car Finance (PCP vs HP)
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments